The school of liars
3 to 10 players
Overview
Taking turns, players try to get a majority of the other players to guess a fallacy card during an improvised skit based on a randomly drawn scenario. While having fun, they learn to recognize, decode and therefore deconstruct fallacious arguments.
Argumentum is based on a classification of these fallacious arguments, arranged into orders and families shown at the top of each card. For example, flattery is a subcategory of appeal to emotions. The memo cards summarize this classification.
Components
- 1 deck of fallacy cards, organized into 7 color-coded classes, each divided into 3 orders and then into 3 families.
- 1 deck of scenario cards, organized into 7 themes identifiable on the backs of the cards.
- Memo cards.
- The game rules.
Setup
Depending on the number of players and the desired difficulty level, build the fallacy-card draw pile by adding the levels shown at the bottom right of the cards, in ascending order. At least 7 x the number of players are needed.
Choose the length of the game. It consists of a succession of rounds lasting about 7 minutes. When the allotted time is up, finish the current round: the player with the most points wins the game. Shuffle the fallacy cards, as well as the scenario cards.
Make 2 draw piles of scenario cards and place them in the middle of the table. Deal each player 5 fallacy cards, which they keep to themselves. The remaining cards form the reserve.
Each player takes a small unique object (coin, bean, etc.) for voting. The first drawer is the player who first remembers a deceptive argument.
Contents
Round sequence
1. The drawer
The drawer takes a scenario card from one of the two available piles and reads it aloud, except for the last sentence in italics at the bottom of the card.
2. The smooth talker
The smooth talker is responsible for steering the scenario's argumentation in order to illustrate one of their fallacy cards. Their goal is to get a majority of the other players to guess this card.
The role of smooth talker is assigned to the first player who places, face down, the fallacy card they intend to play. Otherwise, the player to the drawer's left is designated smooth talker and places their card.
3. The skit
The drawer opens the debate however they wish. They may use the suggested opening line in italics at the bottom of the scenario card. The smooth talker and the drawer then have up to one minute to improvise a discussion during which the smooth talker tries to use the type of argument indicated by the card they chose.
The smooth talker presents their arguments and the drawer responds without trying to dominate the scene. The smooth talker may shorten the skit whenever they wish.
4. The jury
All players except the smooth talker make up the jury, including the drawer. At the end of the skit, each juror chooses, from among their own cards, the one that comes closest to the argumentation they heard and places it face down with the smooth talker's card. With 3 or 4 players, jurors choose 2 cards.
The smooth talker collects the cards, shuffles them and reveals them in the middle of the table. The jurors examine the revealed cards; one juror may read them aloud. Each juror raises a finger to signal that they are ready to vote.
When the jury is ready, without discussion, each member simultaneously indicates the card they think was played by the smooth talker by placing their small unique object on it (or, failing that, their finger).
5. The count
The winner of the round is the player whose card received the greatest number of votes, whether the smooth talker or a member of the jury (π₯ππ…βπ). They then keep their card, which is worth 1 point, and place it face up in front of them.
In the event of a tie (π₯ππβπ₯ππ), the smooth talker wins (β
πβππ). Otherwise (βπ), all tied jurors who received the most votes and identified the smooth talker's card are declared winners (β
ππβππ). If none of the jurors concerned identified it, the smooth talker wins (βππβππ).
6. The draws
Once the winner has been designated, players draw a certain number of cards from the reserve:
- The winner of the round does not draw a new card. (β
πββ0π΄)
- All other players draw one card (βπββ
1π΄), or 2 cards with 3 or 4 players.
- Jury members who received votes draw one additional card. (β
π§²πββ
+1π΄)
- Jurors who found the smooth talker's card draw one additional card. (β
ππββ
+1π΄)
- Played cards are returned to the reserve.
- The winner's left-hand neighbor becomes the drawer for the next round.
Variants
- With 5 or more players, if the smooth talker's card is identified by the entire jury, they do not win the round; everyone draws one card from the reserve, except the smooth talker.
- During the skit, any member of the jury may use a card from their hand to intervene in the role of the drawer. If their intervention illustrates their card well, they draw another and will be designated as the next drawer; otherwise, they lose their card and the game resumes its course.
- The drawer has the right to designate the round's smooth talker directly.
- If the drawer wins, they also win the smooth talker's card.
- The smooth talker may place several cards. As many winners are declared as the smooth talker placed cards, in order of the number of votes; the smooth talker may thus win all or some of their cards.
- The winner of the game must embody the smooth talker in a final scenario in which they must bring into play all the cards they won during the game.