Argumentation
Argumentum explores the art that has endured through the ages and shaped some of the finest pages of our history: argumentation.
The act of arguing differs from expressing oneself, conversing, or giving an opinion, because it involves presenting arguments intended to convince an audience of the validity of facts or decisions.
This gives rise to a formal protocol based on constructing a line of argument, as well as an intellectual code of conduct that enables it to be properly applied.
What is an argument?
An argument consists of a statement called a conclusion, derived from premises or hypotheses that are deemed accepted, through the application of a pattern of reasoning, or inference, that is likewise deemed sound.
This distinguishes an argument from an opinion, because it comes with a justification. All opinions may be admissible, but there are good and bad arguments.
What is a good argument?
To be sound, an argument must meet the following conditions:
- Well-formed structure
No contradictions among the premises or between them and the conclusion.
No truth assumed as a matter of principle, or invalid deduction.
- Premises relevant to the truth of the conclusion
No unnecessary premises; the connections must be explicit.
- Premises acceptable to a reasonable person
Common knowledge, or confirmed by experience.
Supported or supportable by an accessible source.
Uncontested testimony from a competent authority.
The conclusion of another good argument.
A minor proposition constituting a reasonable hypothesis.
- Premises sufficient to demonstrate the conclusion
Difficult to systematize; see certain sciences (statistical samples) or experience
- Refutable premises that effectively rebut anticipated criticism
The most difficult condition, and the one most often missing
Helps distinguish «almost» good arguments.
What is a fallacious argument?
An argument is said to be fallacious if it violates one of the rules that make it sound.
It may involve a structural flaw, irrelevant premises, premises falling below a standard of acceptability, premises insufficient to demonstrate the conclusion, or premises that cannot be refuted.
Yet these few criteria pale beside the astonishing diversity of smooth-talking techniques and mechanisms that make up the bestiary of fallacious arguments.
Argumentum therefore offers a revised classification in the form of a broad hierarchy of 7 families detailing everything that may potentially be fallacious in an argument.
The Argumentum taxonomy of fallacious arguments
This classification, from which the educational material for the Argumentum game is derived, is available in two formats: