The Smooth-Talk Mill
2 to 8 players
Overview
With each round, from a randomly drawn scenario, one of the players finds in a limited time the greatest number of fallacious arguments illustrating the cards drawn in sequence.
Components
- 1 deck of fallacious argument cards organized in 7 color classes, each divided into 3 orders and then in 3 families.
- 1 deck of scenario cards organized in 7 identifiable themes on their back
- Memo cards
- Game rules
Setup
Depending on the number of players and the desired difficulty level, build the fallacious argument card deck by adding the levels indicated at the bottom right of the cards, in ascending order. Choose the maximum number of 3-minute rounds per player to be played.
Shuffle the fallacious argument cards, as well as the scenario cards. Form 2 scenario card decks and 1 fallacious argument deck, then place them in the middle of the table.
The first drawer is the player who most recently conceded an argument through sheer weariness.
Contents
Round sequence
1. The drawer
The drawer draws a scenario card from the two available decks and reads it aloud, except for the last sentence in italics at the bottom of the card.
2. The speed race
The player to the drawer's left is the smooth talker. Set a 3-minute timer.
The smooth talker starts drawing fallacious argument cards. For each card, they must propose an argument that illustrates the card in order to enact the scenario. If they succeed, they win the card; otherwise, they may pass, up to a limit of 3 jokers per round, then draw the next one.
3. End of the round
The round ends when the allotted time runs out. The smooth talker scores as many points as the number of cards they won during the round. They become the drawer for the next round.
End of the game
The first player to reach 20 points wins the game.
Variants
- For each card drawn, after the smooth talker's argument, the other players may each propose another illustration of the card. For each new proposal, the group votes to determine whether it is better than the previous ones. The author of the best accepted proposal wins the card.