Argumentative mixology bingo
1 to 20 players
Overview
Equipped with a bingo grid made up of randomly drawn fallacy cards, players try to spot those illustrated during the debate. At the end of the debate, the player who has spotted the greatest number of fallacious arguments, after validation by a majority of the other players, wins the game.
Components
- 1 debate or 1 speech that the players will attend together and that can be watched again.
- Something to take notes with, and a way to record the time elapsed since the start of the debate.
- 1 or more decks of fallacy cards.
Setup
Randomly distribute all available fallacy cards among the players, at a rate of 10 cards per person. Each player reads their cards, lays them out while trying to keep them as well in mind as possible, then settles in to attend the debate.
Contents
During the debate
Each player listens to the arguments being made. If an argument matches one of the cards on their bingo grid, they note the elapsed time, the beginning of a quotation that will make it possible to find the right passage, and the name of the card. If needed, they add a little context so they can later present their analysis orally.
Post-debate validations
Players claiming the largest number of used cards are selected for validation.
Using their notes and the recording, establish the sequence of moments when each of their cards was used. For each card, replay the relevant moment, and the player explains why the argumentation matches their card. The assembly votes by show of hands to validate or reject their analysis.
Victory conditions
Each player's final score is the number of their cards validated by the assembly. If, after a first count, other non-selected players now have more cards than the best validated score, proceed with their validation, and so on until the best validated score can no longer be challenged.
Players with the best score are declared winners.