Rules | Argumentum
Skip to main content
Home  › ... Rules

The Coinched Chat

4 players

Overview

Over a succession of rounds, 2 teams of 2 players face each other. Players receive hands of fallacious argument cards, which they use in turn on a randomly drawn scenario. The level of specificity of the cards determines their strength. Two colors, called trump colors, may be played at any time and prevail over the other colors. In addition to recognizing fallacious arguments, players practice assessing the level of specificity of the cards and cooperating.

Components

  • 1 deck of fallacious argument cards, organized into 7 color classes, each divided into 3 orders and then 3 families. A selection of 28 cards
  • 1 deck of scenario cards, organized into 7 themes identifiable on the backs of the cards
  • Memo cards
  • Game rules

Setup

Select 28 fallacious argument cards for the game, 4 per color.

Shuffle the fallacious argument cards and the scenario cards separately. Form 2 scenario card draw piles and place them in the middle of the table.

The first drawer is the player who lied most recently.

Contents

Start of the round

1. The drawer

The drawer draws a scenario card from the two available decks and reads it aloud, except for the last sentence in italics at the bottom of the card.

They then shuffle the 28 fallacious argument cards and deal them to the 4 players.

2. Trump bidding

Starting with the player to the drawer's left, players choose whether or not to raise the bid in order to designate the 2 trump colors for the round. Trump cards make it possible to beat other types of cards and are also worth more points during the round scoring.

Trump bidding starts at 80, then bids increase by 10.

At any time, one of the two members of a team may say “I coinche” to end the bidding and double the stakes of the round.

When no one raises any further, the two trump colors are designated for the round and the play phase can begin.

3. The turns of play

For 7 turns, each player confronts 1 fallacious argument card with the scenario.

Starting with the player to the drawer's left, each player must propose a card and formulate an illustrative argument responding to the scenario's injunction.

If no trump card is played, the card with the highest depth level wins the trick.

If trump cards are played, the trump card with the lowest depth level wins the trick.

Players on the same team share the tricks they win.

To win a trick, a player must make explicit an argument corresponding to their card.

If no player proposes an argument, the best card wins.

4. Round scoring

The round ends when all tricks have been played.

Then count the points for both teams.

For cards that are not in the trump colors, each card is worth 2 times its depth level.

For cards in the trump colors, each card is worth 12 - (2 times its depth level).

If the team that won the trump bidding fulfills its contract with a higher score, it scores the amount of its bid plus the points actually won.

If the other team wins, it scores 160 points plus the amount of the bid that was not fulfilled.

If the bidding was coinched, the scores are doubled.

End of the game and scoring

The winning team is the first to exceed 1000 points.